Opening decklid when stuck in traffic?

Early Bay Forum

Help Support Early Bay Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

strutt

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
284
Reaction score
0
Location
Coventry
Hi,

I was driving to V festival last weekend in my car and passed a fella in a bay who had opened his engine lid obiously to try and increase cooling whilst stuck in traffic!

I was of 2 opinions about this and wondered if i would have done the same as the bumper get hot on my van from the exhaust.
So can someone please clear up my confusion.....should you open it or leave it closed when stuck in a jam?

Thanks
Luke
 
the top end of the engine should stay cold at all times so like you say opening the lid will just suck in heat from exhaust etc
fan assisted cold air into the top of the engine bay would work ie somehow speeding the air in from the rear cresent vents or piping in cold air from the front under the van. or failing that. a nic huge oil cooler under the van with scoop, fan and thermostat.
 
Well that solves that then......
just that your hear about overheating in jams etc.......
then on the other hand you hear a great deal about how vw designed an engine for all conditions!

Cheers
 
when I was watching the bays in the tour de france coming down the hill [well mountain]they all had their decklids open..

I am convinced when driving up inclines etc it`s a good thing ,in traffic jams no...
 
I was driving to V festival last weekend in my car and passed a fella in a bay who had opened his engine lid obiously to try and increase cooling whilst stuck in traffic!

Most stupid thing you can do, you just suck up the hot cooling/exhaust air that is behind your bus.
When i'm bussy with my engine on the driveway with open decklid it warms up very quick you can feel that it is sucking up the hot air, with closed decklid i needs twice the time to warm up at the same level.
 
dandaz said:
when I was watching the bays in the tour de france coming down the hill [well mountain]they all had their decklids open..

I am convinced when driving up inclines etc it`s a good thing ,in traffic jams no...

I disagree, no more cold air will be sucked by opening the decklid, the rear vents are hardly restrictive and if anything their scooped design should pressurise the upper half of the engine bay slightly. I think people think that your letting heat out, but there shouldnt be a significant amount of heat in the upper half of the engine bay anyway, if there is then your tinware is not doing its job! I also understand that the aerodynamics of a bay make the engine bay suck in the hot gasses when the vans moving due to the slight vacume/turbulence behind the vehicle. I once accidently left my engine bay open, 20 minutes later my engine had barely any power and was super hot, i closed the engine lid and everything was fine again!
 
My engine dosent get hotter sat in traffic, but if i left the engine running with the lid open while working on the bus it dose get very warm.
Its always been a bone of contension and the Taxis in egypt (bays) all seem to run with the engine lid welded open. Cant imagine VW would design something that you had to get out and open the door to cool it down mid journey.
 
last year i did 60mph and a traffic jam fully loaded in 42 degrees in italy and my engine was fine ! unlike me who wobbled into the services with a bit of dehydration for a coke asap !!! :lol:

chris
 
Trikky2 said:
It should not get too hot in the first place. If it does theres something wrong.

indeed trikky!
Ive never seen in any manual that you have to open the lid!
good 30 grade oil , all tin and seals in place they will tick over for ages even on hot summer days
 
luke said:
dandaz said:
when I was watching the bays in the tour de france coming down the hill [well mountain]they all had their decklids open..

I am convinced when driving up inclines etc it`s a good thing ,in traffic jams no...

I disagree, no more cold air will be sucked by opening the decklid, the rear vents are hardly restrictive and if anything their scooped design should pressurise the upper half of the engine bay slightly.

See I don`t buy this pressurising , because behind my fan in the singlecab is a huge open space it would be impossible to even slightly pressurise it...

I have seen or heard lots of bay findinding it hard over the hills ,too much work =not enough speed ,these bays had already flew over the Alps and where into the pyraneese ,me thinks it is a good idea ,my decklid was open and the engine thanked me... 8)
 
IMO the most important thing is to be sure all engine seals and tinware are in place and in good condition this will keep the cool half of the engine cool and the hot half hot. Opening the engine lid with engine running is not a clever thing to do :D :D
 
dandaz said:
luke said:
dandaz said:
when I was watching the bays in the tour de france coming down the hill [well mountain]they all had their decklids open..

I am convinced when driving up inclines etc it`s a good thing ,in traffic jams no...

I disagree, no more cold air will be sucked by opening the decklid, the rear vents are hardly restrictive and if anything their scooped design should pressurise the upper half of the engine bay slightly.

See I don`t buy this pressurising , because behind my fan in the singlecab is a huge open space it would be impossible to even slightly pressurise it...

I have seen or heard lots of bay findinding it hard over the hills ,too much work =not enough speed ,these bays had already flew over the Alps and where into the pyraneese ,me thinks it is a good idea ,my decklid was open and the engine thanked me... 8)


:lol: :lol: :lol: It genuinly amuses me the amount of old wives tales and myths that develop. It has got much much worse with the rise of the internet, where new ones keep sprouting up and then get repeated by others at an exponential rate.

For example :- Its taken years and many thousands of words, posts, arguments and flamings to finally get some of the VW aircooled owners to accept that throwing away the stock distributor and replacing it with an 009 is not an improvement or a way of making it go faster. The only time an 009 would be an improvement is when the original is very badly worn and a correct replacement is un available.

I know its tempting but just because its an old vehicle doesent mean you can just ignore the manufacturer and make up new recommendations of your own. I was involved with these vehicles, working for Volkswagen Technical at the time these vehicles were being developed and produced.

Please dont start another myth.

Just because you see some stupid people running around with the engine lid open doesent mean its a good idea. Monkey see monkey do.

If we had found that taking the cooling air from the rear worked then we would have built them with grills in the engine lid and we could have saved ourselves the cost, space and complexity of building the vehicles with the air scoops high on the side of the vehicle. Those scoops are not a fake "go faster" styling feature to make the bus look good.

The scoops are there to ensure the air for the engine is as cool and dust free as possible.

There is a rubber seal on the rear engine lid to prevent hot air, exhaust gases and dust from being drawn into the engine. Leaving the engine lid open has a similar effect to leaving some of the tinware off, in that it allows hot air from under the engine to be drawn back in. Dust not only causes premature clogging of the air filter but can also collect in the cooling system fins and reduce their ability to dissipate heat.

The scoops do cause a small but measureable amount of ram air effect at speed. This positive pressure is not enough to significantly affect engine performance but it is enough to cause slight positive pressure which stops the fan sucking past the engine seals.

People who leave their engine lids open clearly have no understanding of how the air flows over, round and under a moving vehicle - I would have thought the seal round the engine and round the engine lid might give them a clue - but apparently not enough for those with IQ's in the double figures.
 
AGC said:
IMO the most important thing is to be sure all engine seals and tinware are in place and in good condition this will keep the cool half of the engine cool and the hot half hot. Opening the engine lid with engine running is not a clever thing to do :D :D

i understand the seals are important but how tight should they fit? i fitted all new stuff to my engine and there are small air gaps between tinware and valance seal :shock: dont know how to rectify as the tinware must be a little small :roll:
 
I would imagaine someone was driving along on a motorway the temp was around 200 F and they came into a large traffic jam and thort oh i better open the engine lid to help with cooling. Then after a few minutes they noticed the temp gauge going down so believed it had worked. Then told all there mates and it got passed around.

When we all know that when you are stuck in traffic the engine temp will reduce anyway.
 
Cheers for the replys.....

i know its off the topic slightly, but i recently fitted new tinware (lower 3 pieces), brought this from heritage and tbh the fit was rubbish, i managed to get it to fit better however it still have small gaps on the sides that touched the engine, is this normal or should it be totally flush against the engine.
I know i will loose a slight ammount of airflow through the gaps, but was wondering how critical it would be?


I have only owned my bay since january and seen so many cock-ups and various old wives tales its unreal!!!!
Thanks
 
I have always assumed that the fit of the tinware and engine bay seals was critical to the correct temperature of the engine, so I would say that the correct fit is very important.Even unsealed bolt holes or small rusted through areas will have a detremental effect. By the way, when I owned a Splitty which was imported from Arizona it had an aftermarket "air scoop" fitted. This consisted of a rectangular funnel (2 inches wide by approx 10 inches long bolted to the chassis facing towards the front of the van. Attached to the funnel was a 2 inch diam. tube that passed through the bottom of the van into the engine bay. When the van was driving along cold air was scooped into the funnel and passed into the engine bay via the tube to keep everything cool. It worked very well. the only problems were that it also scooped water in if it rained and dust if it was very dry. Because the splitty air vents are not as efficient as the bay type this really helped to keep the engine cool.
 

Latest posts

Top